Another article: How Pristine Were Our Ecosystems Before?

Talk related to anything & everything.
Post Reply
User avatar
hound_hunter
Monster
Monster
Posts: 1190
Joined: Sun Dec 11, 2005 5:13 pm
Location: Utah

Another article: How Pristine Were Our Ecosystems Before?

Post by hound_hunter » Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:47 pm

Got the day off and ran across this article. I liked it, thought a couple of you might too.
http://alaskahuntingtoday.com/blog/inde ... n/#more-56

How Pristine Were Our Ecosystems Before Western Exploration?

February 9, 2010

Oh, if only we could return to the days before man got into our wilderness areas and destroyed everything. Imagine how wonderful it must have been. Nature doing a fine job all on its own and then all of a sudden man expands his reach and destroys it all.

This is what I hear all the time. Even our education factories teach our kids this inaccurate history. Few have ever heard of what it was really like. I know I have had many discussions with people about the Lewis and Clark Expedition. I admit I was one of those who dreamed about how wonderful it must have been. What could be more exciting to a man who loved the outdoors than to be a member of the Lewis and Clark troop? This would provide a participant the opportunity to see the forests, the plains, the rivers, the valleys, the birds, deer, moose, elk, bison, mountain goats, wild sheep, tons of beaver, muskrat, mink, lynx, bobcat, mountain lions, coyotes, wolves, oh, my. What am I forgetting. I might have been in for a rude awakening had I been there.

Lewis and Clark mounted their expedition from around 1804-1806 and their journey was quite well documented. We know that they took along “professional” hunters and trappers to provide food for the members. Logs show Lewis and Clark spent much of their time trading with Indians for dogs to eat because there was no game.

During the years of 1825-1860, Jedediah Smith, Peter Skeen Ogden, Milton Sublette, Joe Meek, John Fremont, Charles Preuss, Captain J. H. Simpson, and Howard Egan, explored all over the West, both on foot and horseback. They kept diaries and logs of their adventures and these accounts describe a much different picture of what it was really like before man moved into this region and settled.

Jedediah Smith is believed to be one of the first explorers of this region. In 1827, Smith and what was described as two of his best men, set out up the American River, through Central Nevada and ending up at Lake Lake, Utah. Smith’s log describes this trip accordingly.

After traveling 22 days from the east side of Mount Joseph, (Sierra Nevada’s) I struck the Southwest corner of the Great Salt Lake, traveling over a country completely barren and destitute of game. We frequently traveled without water, sometime for two days, over sandy deserts where there was no sign of vegetation and when we found water in some of the rocky hills we most generally found Indians who appeared the most miserable of the human race. When we arrived at the Salt Lake, we had but one horse and one mule remaining, which were so feeble and poor that they could scarcely carry the little camp equipage which I had along. The balance of my horses I was compelled to eat.

This expedition originally began with 14 men and 28 horses.

In 1828 Peter Skeen Ogden led an expedition into North Central Nevada. In an area that is now near Winnemucca, Nevada on the Humboldt River (Marys River), what was seen is described this way.

From clumps of sage on the hillsides, scrawny, brown-bodied men peered out upon their passage. Down in the Valley, now and again, the Indians scurried into the brush ahead of them. They were clothed, if at all, in twisted rabbit skins; They had no horses. They lived on seeds, and what wild fowl they could bring down. Ogden had never encountered a race of animals less entitled to the name of man.

The following year Ogden returned to the same area to do some trapping on the river. He describes the river as being very “unwholesome” and says the antelope, which during this time would be near the rivers are scarce. He declares, “woe to them who depend to them for support”.

In 1832 Milton Sublette led a group of trappers into the Marys River (Humboldt). There was no game and the trappers had to eat the beavers they had been trapping. His reports stated that there was not much for what wild animals there were to eat and that they were forced to eat wild parsnips, which poisoned them. The group had to leave this area and head north where they hoped to find something to eat.

Because of this it became necessary to at once abandon the river, and strike across the country towards the North, where after being four days with almost no food, and several weeks in the state of famine they reached the Snake River above the fishing Falls, they were forced, as they passed through the country, to subsist upon ants, crickets, parched moccasins, and the pudding made from the blood, taking a pint at a time from their almost famished animals.

Joe Meek recalls holding his bare hands in an anthill until they were covered with angry ants and then licking the ants off and eating them like a hungry animal.

Joe Walker later traveled through this same Marys River area and continued on into California near the Truckee River down the West Slope of the Sierra Nevada Mountains. Having left Salt Lake and traveling 14 days into California, the expedition had not seen any game to eat and instead lived off horses they were compelled to kill to ward off starvation.

One man killed a deer, which he carried to camp on his back. The animal was dressed, cooked and eaten, … in less time than a hungry wolf would devour a lamb. This was the first game larger than a rabbit that they had killed since leaving the Salt Lake two months ago. For fourteen days they had lived on nothing but horseflesh …twenty four horses had died in crossing the mountain, and seventeen of these had been eaten.

1825 and 1826 found Ogden covering much of what we all know as Oregon today and not only did his group not find any game but the horses were starving because they couldn’t find even any decent grasses for the horse to feed on. It wasn’t just the explorers finding these wastelands. Ogden relates a story told of an Indian woman in Oregon.

The winter before had been so severe, she said, that her people had to resort to the bodies of relations and children. She had killed no one herself, but had fed on two of her children who died.

Things are pretty harsh when anyone has to resort to cannibalism but to first have to kill somebody to eat them, is unfathomable.

John Fremont and Charles Preuss covered areas of Southern Wyoming west toward the Bear River and then South toward Salt Lake. Things were tough. Game was missing and grazing grasses for the horses were non existent as well. Explorers tried trading with the Indian for food but soon discovered the Indians were starving to death themselves. It was only upon finding the Shoshone camped out along the Snake River, were they able to find a tribe living well from ample supplies of smoked Salmon.

Fremont’s party traveled the Columbia River north into Vancouver finding much the same. They even had to buy firewood from some of the resident Indians. Heading south toward Nevada, local tribes warned Fremont there was nothing for his horses to feed on. They were right.

… They had found nothing but dry, shallow basins, their way “broken by gullies and impeded by sage, and sandy on the hills, where there is not a blade of grass.”

Later Fremont would find Pyramid Lake and gorge on trout.

In all of the travels that are documented by many of these explorers, in what is now the state of Nevada, only one time is there mention of someone sighting an elk, but it is believed the person saw a mule deer and mistook it for an elk.

The Indians in this region mostly lived terrible lives, with little clothing, food or sufficient shelter. They ate mostly rats and insects and what few other birds or small game they might be fortunate to find and kill. We have visions of Indians having access to ample game animals and utilizing the hides for clothing and shelter. Such was not the case in most of the Great Basin.

Howard Egan, Sr. was the first Mormon explorer into the region of the Great Salt Lake. As a matter of fact he traveled there with Brigham Young. Egan covered much of the area between the Salt Lake and west into California as he was in the business of driving cattle there.

Egan recounts for us how the Indians crafted these remarkable corrals they would use to trap antelope. The entire episode of putting on a drive required all the men, women and children of the tribe. One had to question whether the effort put into the building and driving was worth the 24 antelope they trapped in twelve years. But when you’re hungry, some antelope is better than none.

The Indians did a similar thing conducting a cricket drive. No, I’m not kidding. Trenches were dug of about 1 foot wide by 1 foot deep and covered over with a thin layer of stiff grass. All the tribes people would begin pounding the ground with tufts of straw in a concerted effort, to drive the black crickets toward the trenches. Once the trenches contained all the crickets they could drive, they set the grass they had placed over the trenches on fire, killing the crickets. They then used the crickets for food, mostly grinding it up and mixing it with other things to make a concocted kind of flour.

These and more accounts certainly paint a far different picture of how things actually were than what we are often taught about how balanced and bountiful our forests and wilderness were before man arrived. Man certainly made his share of mistakes in being good stewards of the land but in time we figured out what we had to do to sustain game populations and to control the predators that destroyed those.

With the presence of man and bringing with him agriculture and the knowledge to plant and grow crops and tend the land, this began to create a better habitat that would support a heartier and healthier crop of game animals. We controlled the predators so people could harvest the game to feed their families and over time devised a pretty decent wildlife management plan that many around the world now envy.

Sorry, but Mother Nature didn’t really give us a “balanced” ecosystem, at least one that is the most productive. These accounts above I believe more accurately depict Mother Nature’s idea of a balanced ecosystem. There’s nothing wrong with that but I don’t think it is in the best interest of humans to have it that way, nor is it what I think people really want or are thinking about when they speak of “natural” wildlife management.

Tom Remington

TheGreatwhitehunter
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2117
Joined: Sun Jul 09, 2006 1:00 am
Location: COLORADO

Re: Another article: How Pristine Were Our Ecosystems Before?

Post by TheGreatwhitehunter » Fri Feb 12, 2010 12:47 am

:good post
THE LORD IS MY ROCK

Image
Image
Image

User avatar
sneekeepete
Monster
Monster
Posts: 1757
Joined: Tue Sep 23, 2008 1:15 pm
Location: Utah

Re: Another article: How Pristine Were Our Ecosystems Before?

Post by sneekeepete » Fri Feb 12, 2010 6:55 am

TheGreatwhitehunter wrote::good post
+1 that was a great post thanks for sharing it with us!
SNEEKEEPETE
OIF Vet.
Sgt Petersen USMC
Colossians 1:27,28

User avatar
79Ford
Monster
Monster
Posts: 849
Joined: Mon Nov 27, 2006 12:07 am
Location: Vernal, Utah
Contact:

Re: Another article: How Pristine Were Our Ecosystems Before?

Post by 79Ford » Fri Feb 12, 2010 11:36 am

Not how I thought it was back then. Thanks for posting!

User avatar
brn2hunt
4 point
4 point
Posts: 598
Joined: Fri Apr 27, 2007 7:27 am
Location: South Dakota

Re: Another article: How Pristine Were Our Ecosystems Before?

Post by brn2hunt » Fri Feb 12, 2010 7:14 pm

Never thought it was like that!
"Ne A La Chasse"

m gardner
Monster
Monster
Posts: 768
Joined: Mon Feb 18, 2008 5:24 am
Location: Mesa, Arizona
Contact:

Re: Another article: How Pristine Were Our Ecosystems Before?

Post by m gardner » Sat Feb 13, 2010 9:09 am

Good post. I remember the stories passed down and told when I was a child. It was a remarkable life then. Remarkable if you survived past 30 years of age. The stories are no longer passed down from generation to generation and the old people are not held in any esteem. So young people are educated by the acedemic elite and the government now. Pretty dangerous. In this deteriorating social experiment that is wrapping up right now we may get to be heavily selected against once again. Few have a clue just how unglamorous life will become.
Thanks for the reminder.
Mark

User avatar
Hiker
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2846
Joined: Mon Jan 30, 2006 11:33 am
Location: Montana

Re: Another article: How Pristine Were Our Ecosystems Before?

Post by Hiker » Sat Feb 13, 2010 11:45 am

m gardner wrote:Good post. I remember the stories passed down and told when I was a child. It was a remarkable life then. Remarkable if you survived past 30 years of age. The stories are no longer passed down from generation to generation and the old people are not held in any esteem. So young people are educated by the acedemic elite and the government now. Pretty dangerous. In this deteriorating social experiment that is wrapping up right now we may get to be heavily selected against once again. Few have a clue just how unglamorous life will become.
Thanks for the reminder.
Mark
Well put! :good post
Hiker

Proverbs 3:5-6

User avatar
hound_hunter
Monster
Monster
Posts: 1190
Joined: Sun Dec 11, 2005 5:13 pm
Location: Utah

Re: Another article: How Pristine Were Our Ecosystems Before?

Post by hound_hunter » Sat Feb 13, 2010 8:26 pm

I'm glad you all found it as interesting as I did. And great insight Mark, it definitely leaves something to think about!

Post Reply
cron