what guide services in AZ lack ethics?

in the last few years I have heard several stories/ complaints regarding guides in my state, attempting to bully and discourage hunters. Az has a first come first served stance, and they don't seem to respect it. I have seen empty bleach bottles near tanks.I have had them set up right next to me on ridges and tanks I even had them pull trees across roads to discourage me from hunting an area. I am not sure if I can mention their name but they're from the cottonwood area. I have heard several like stories from friends and other hunters. If I can post their name let me know. But the reason for this post is the word needs to be out there. I have made complaints to the authority having jurisdictions and now its time to notify the people who really matter, do to lack of interest from those groups.Hunting isnt only for people who can afford to pay $5000.-$10,000 for guided hunts. Its for all, even those poor hunters like me I think its time to get the word out about these groups and maybe affect their hunting experience instead. Does anyone have similar stories
33,526
TheGreatwhitehunter
It does not only happen in Arizona. There are outfitters who do similar things here in Colorado to like setting up there whole main camp right in the middle of a open Forest service road. Or guys on horses pushing all the elk to private land 2 days before the season opens. Or when they use vehicles to run up and down a road to keep the elk from leaving the private land. :>/ #-o \

Try turning them in and see if anyone bothers to pursue an investigation it can be a real joke to try to bring any justice on these people. ](*,)
38
Default Avatar
Man, those are some dirty tactics. Unbelievable.
38
rimrocknewt
*raises hand...lol
i know but will remain quiet :thumb
38
Default Avatar
have you talked with the outfitting service? or the warden in that area?
38
Default Avatar
Hunting 1/2 mile from private land. Guy on horse comes up to me to make sure I know where land line is and that I will be prosecuted if I get on their land. This was first words out of his mouth. A--hole. Stayed with a couple hundred yards of me for about 30 min. riding horse on public land trying to guide elk back on private land. It was intense as words passed back in forth but, he got his way, ruined my hunt. What's with this??? I feel your pain, something should be done but, forest ranger says nothing can be done, they didn't break laws!!
38
Default Avatar
"iditarodgrizzly" wrote:Hunting 1/2 mile from private land. Guy on horse comes up to me to make sure I know where land line is and that I will be prosecuted if I get on their land. This was first words out of his mouth. A--hole. Stayed with a couple hundred yards of me for about 30 min. riding horse on public land trying to guide elk back on private land. It was intense as words passed back in forth but, he got his way, ruined my hunt. What's with this??? I feel your pain, something should be done but, forest ranger says nothing can be done, they didn't break laws!!
i can't believe that!!this just pisses me off reading about it.
well up on the strip during the archery hunt my dad went to a tank around noon to check his cam and some other hunters were there putting up a groundblind and my dad said he could hear them pissin n moanin about my dad being there and later that day my dad was driving by and saw a trash bag over his camera!
38
spoofman
its is too bad we couldnt ride our horse just inside the private property and tell them to stay off the public ground or they were going to be in trouble just to ruin their hunt....but that would be illegal....symantics if you ask me....there should be a law prohibitting harrassment of fellow hunters...IMHO
38
one hunting fool
I know of a big well known guide service in Utah that does the same thing. He even goes to the Land owners and offers them money if his clients kill trophy animals on their land discouraging land owners to grant permission to other hunters that have drawn "limited entry" tags. I feel the same as you on this page but how can regular guys compete with high dollar outfits?
38
Default Avatar
There are always few who spoil name of whole group
38
Default Avatar
Man this thread is making me sick... it's too bad that guys will go to tactics like this. I've heard of outfitters in my area contacting LE tag holders and basically forcing them to hire them. If not, the guides will push the elk out of the areas. Not entirely sure on how much truth there is to it, but it definitely makes me nervous and ticked!
38
derekp1999
My family has property in Utah that is smack in between several CWMUs. We've had the CWMU operator from one unit "guiding" his clients onto our land for moose. Interestingly enough we'd give him all the permission in the world to do so if he paid the trespass fee... but with his "entitlement issues" you can guess how that went over. Now we have the DWR and the County Sheriff's backing us and he's been "removed" from the property by the authorities on more than one occasion. I haven't heard of any problems with him in the last 5 or so moose seasons.
This same guy would also send his minions on horseback onto our property to push the small elk herd onto his for "his paying clients." He hasn't done it in the last 15 years or so... because the elk were removed (State traded them to Kentucky for a bunch of turkey, crap trade IMO). I would venture to guess we might start seeing it again as a handful of elk have moved back onto our property.
No one state or group or area is immune to this, as long as big dollar signs flash in these "guides" heads, they will always try this crap.
It's especially irritating when Everyday Joe tries antics like this though. I had a trail camera moved (the guy pointed it up towards the sky) when he came across it on the archery hunt. Not sure why a guy would feel the need or desire to do that... make a face at it or maybe a gesture and move on, leave it alone.
38
gizmo1
i do know that many states have laws against intentionally disturbing one's hunt. Texas does and Colorado does (or at least used to). The other end is getting anyone one to do anything about it. It is a misdemeanor crime and has to be in the presence of a law enforcement official, i.e. the game warden, before it is enforceable. It is terrible that we live in a time that this has become common place.
38
TheHardWay
"gizmo1" wrote:i do know that many states have laws against intentionally disturbing one's hunt. Texas does and Colorado does (or at least used to). The other end is getting anyone one to do anything about it. It is a misdemeanor crime and has to be in the presence of a law enforcement official, i.e. the game warden, before it is enforceable. It is terrible that we live in a time that this has become common place.

Still is. Rule #18 in the "It's against the law to:" section. "Interfere with hunters. This includes distracting or frightening prey; causing prey to flee by using light or noise; chasing prey on foot or by vehicle; throwing objects; making movements; harassing hunters by using threats or actions; erecting barriers to deny access to hunting areas and intentionally injecting yourself int the line of fire. Violators face prosecution and may have to pay victim's damages and court costs."

I have no time for these big time outfitters that pull stunts like this. I have heard of several instances of a paticular outfitter in Utah, who happens to also have a line of DVD videos, pull this crap. Hooligans putting up signs telling other hunters to keep out of an area because they are filming a hunt. I can't personally claim that I have seen it, since I have yet to draw a Utah tag :>/, but I have heard it from friends that have hunted there. Makes me want to punch this guy right between the eyes.
38
Default Avatar
I had a had a terrible experience with an outfitter outside of Tuscon. The whole experience blew up into a violation being cited, not towards the outfitter though! After talking to the warden, he said that outfitter has been in hot water a few times. All we can do is hope that one day actions catch up to this outfitters and others that don't do it the ethical responsible way!
38