Which buck would you shoot?

Ok you guys. If these two bucks were side by side and you have to choose between one of them which would you take, a 30" wide 3 point or a heavier 5 X 4.




http://i61.photobucket.com/albums/h71/ackc10/IMG_0123.jpg" alt="" />


http://i61.photobucket.com/albums/h71/ackc10/IMG_0124.jpg" alt="" />
9,243
MuleyMadness
hmm...good question???

Boy, that 3 point sure does look impressive!

Don't tempt me like that.

But I think I'd prolly take heavier one.

:thumb
13
bigbuck92
id take either one it depends on the body size so i could see how much jerky on them. but if they were around the same size id probaly take the 5 X 4
13
Default Avatar
I would hammer the heavy one!!! For sure. The wide one doesn't have that much horn at all...spread is one measurment and its still only air
13
waynedevore
I would take the 5x4, that sure is a nice 3 pt though.

mnmt
13
a_bow_nut
I would take the three point my self. Not worried about the width just like the symetrical look myself.
13
Default Avatar
which ever gave me a shot first. :thumb
13
Default Avatar
Number two. Although #1 is a dandy.
13
Default Avatar
"heelerdog" wrote:Number two. Although #1 is a dandy.
 Ditto!
13
Default Avatar
the one on the right my son would take the one on the left :) I would go for the 3x my self I need a good 3x for the shop
13
9er
id take the 5x4

9er
13
Default Avatar
[I would take the three point my self. Not worried about the width just like the symetrical look myself.]

Have to say that is the comment that makes the most since to me. But I think that I would take the 4X5 because I already have a buck similar to that 3 point. In fact the picture is on this page. Mine was pretty cool with devil tines and great width, right around 32 inches. Look it up.
13
Default Avatar
Id shoot the one with the red X
13
bowhunter 616
which ever one gave me a good clean shot [-o<
13
HighLander
Whichever one walk out first and gives me the besy shot...both very nice animals.
13